Send Young Offenders To Eton

SOCIAL POLICY

Three hours


Answer one question. Explain your reasoning, using additional paper if necessary. When you are finished, hand your paper in to the Secretary of State for Children, Schools and Families.


Question 1
It costs £9,360 (not including music lessons, fencing and boat club membership) to send 15-year-old Toby to Eton for the three-month Michaelmas term. It costs the state an average of £9,777 (not including the cost of his crime) to send Karl to a young offenders institute for three months for committing a string of car thefts.

Why doesn’t the state send Karl to the nation’s premier school, expand his horizons somewhat and pocket the difference to pay back the national debt?

513-eton2

It really is that simple. The issue that this mathematical exercise highlights cuts right to the heart of modern social policy and ought to make any liberal extremely uneasy in their defence of the state as the ultimate provider of services in the children’s sector.

We hold no torch for the private education system, and believe that such issues as the charitable status of private schools – which saves them almost £100m a year in tax breaks – is an anomaly that is unacceptable for organsations that charge so much yet provide so little service to the wider community.

Yet we feel that there must be something at play when schools are able to protect, house, teach, exercise and entertain children at a lower rate than the state – and make a profit while doing it. Surely we should be open enough to accept the ideas of the private sector into state activities when they seem to be working. (OK, as the shadow cabinet proves, attendance at Eton is no guarantee against anti-social behaviour, but you get our drift.)

The statistical truth is that passage through such institutions as Eton can only bring good things into the life of a youth. The opportunities, be they on the sporting field, where the virtues of teamwork could be inculcated, in the classroom or just in an environment where routine and clear responsibilities would be a new world to children who have been failed by the pastoral care of the state, are legion.

Bringing young men with next to no opportunities into their life into such a system as Eton offers is a no-brainer, on both sides. The programme would also lead to a greater understanding of wider society for Eton pupils, and could foster some much needed community spirit among a generation of future hedge funders and politicians.

To any complaints that the figures are not equivalent, consider this. The £3,259 a month (£40,000 a year) that the state must find to look after young offenders is averaged out from children in secure facilities and in the community, so the median individual is not a murderer in a high-security unit needing top level care which a private school couldn’t provide. And to accusations of social engineering, we plead guilty.

As ever, we welcome you thoughts and suggestions…

4 responses to “Send Young Offenders To Eton

  1. And it costs £178,000pa to send a young offender to a privately run Secure Training Centre.

    It’s tragic the way our ‘civilised’ societies treat children in care, whether in the care of a religious or government institution. We’re currently investigating the brutal restraining techniques used in UK Young Offenders Institutions and Childcare homes.

    Bill Maloney and Pie ‘n’ Mash Films have been working on a documentary with 22 men who were all sexually abused by senior prison office ‘Neville Husband’ back in the 70s and who are now in the process of taking the Home Office to court. We also discovered that the youngest child in English custody Adam Rickwood (14) committed suicide at the same detention centre only four years ago. We have interviews with Adam’s family who do not believe he committed suicide and with four of the men who were abused back in the 70s at the same centre. Ligatures and torture techniques were used! Please take a few minutes to view the trailer for ‘Adam Rickwood & The Medomsley Heroes’: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D34cshT2vto&feature=channel_page and leave your comments. (Warning: Videos contain strong language)

    Feel free to push our information out to any links/forums you think relevant.

    If we all pull together we CAN make a difference.

    These ARE the Medomsley Heroes: http://www.justice4survivors.org
    We are http://www.pienmashfilms.com

  2. I somehow dont agree with a few things, but its great anyways.

  3. appealing answers i like it

  4. Because Karl might not be intelligent enough, or have been properly educated pre-imprisonment, to do well at Eton. That would just be setting Karl up for failure. Not to mention that Eton is for 5 years, not three months.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s